facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterest

Smart Scales. What they are and why you want one.

 

You’re trying to lose weight. You’re tracking your calories with one of our recommended meal trackers. You’re tracking your activity with one of many popular activity trackers. Are you tracking your progress? We review some of the best (and not so great) Smart Scales on the market. Smart Scales, like the popular Weight Gurus Digital Body Fat Scale with Smartphone Tracking, track your progress and sync with many of today’s popular fitness apps either via wifi or bluetooth. One more way to simplify your life and health journey! Check back soon to learn why a Smart Scale may be just the thing you need, and use our reviews to determine which scale is right for you.

 

Withings WS-50 Smart Body Analyzer

3.6 Our Overall Score
0 User Overall Score (0 votes)
Summary of Pros
  • Tracks weight loss
  • Easy to use
  • Saves multiple users' data and recognizes you
  • Automatically syncs your data
  • Syncs with multiple health apps
  • Fun novelty features
  • Appealing Design
  • Summary of Cons
  • Accuracy and consistency issues
  • Software bugs
  • User recognition glitches
  • Customer support is hit or miss
  • Some features need work
  • In Depth Analysis
         
    The Good:
     
  • Setup: Easy, fast setup over WiFi or Bluetooth.
  • User Profiles: Saves user profiles for you and other users.
  • Step Right Up: No calibration before you weight in. Just step right onto the scale.
  • User Recognition: Built to recognize you when you step onto the device.
  • Auto Sync: Automatically syncs your data to whatever apps you utilize when you weigh in.
  • Average Weight: Calculates and provides your average weight over a period of time.
  • History: Stores and gives you access to your entire weigh-in history.
  • Has its own App: Works with the Withings Healthmate App, an app available with all Withings products.
  • Syncs with Apps: Syncs with Fitbit, MyFitnessPal, Apple Health Kit, Google Fitness, Runkeeper, and more.
  • Novelty features: Has a CO2 Monitor that tells you the air quality in the room. Retrieves and provides weather and temperature info.
  • Accurate in comparison: Considered accurate compared to other scales in its price-range.
  • Never lose data: If network is down, the scale keeps a record of your weigh-in and updates when reconnected.
  •    
    The Bad:
     
  • Weight Accuracy: Although said to be more accurate than other scales in its price range, it does not give perfectly accurate readouts.
  • Body-fat Accuracy: Body-fat% is very inaccurate and varies. However, it does save the data and therefore show trends over time.
  • Consistency: Users find a lack of consistency. Weighing in three times in a row can give different readouts that vary by ounces.
  • Sync issues: Some users report issues with syncing, such as instances of data not syncing at all. This does not appear to be a common occurrence.
  • App and Site inconsistencies: The App and websitesite are sometimes not displaying the same readings. This happens specifically when data is deleted from one of the two, and the change doesn't appear in the other.
  • Multi-user bugs: Multi-user profiles can be glitchy, sometimes not properly detecting who stepped on the scale.
  • Needs development: Some users say they feel like they're testing a beta product.
  • Iffy Customer Support: Customer Support is a hit or miss, with some users complaining it's more miss than hit.
  • Features that fall short: Built in heart rate monitor is essentially worthless giving wildly inaccurate readouts.
  •    
    Final Word
      The Withings WS-50 is good, just not fantastic. The scale has been available since 2013 and upon initial release many users were critical. Over time, software updates and tweaks improved performance and user feedback improved in response. If you're a techy who enjoys watching a product grow in quality, you may not mind the software bugs. If you love the novelty features like CO2 readings and weather, you'll have fun with this scale. The Heart Rate monitoring is still useless. If you want your heart rate to help determine your calories burned, or because you need or simply want to keep track, click here now and pick up a highly rated heart monitor.
    Hardware
    Software
    Ease of Use
    Fun Factor
    Cost/Value
    What people say about the product... Leave your rating
    Sort by:

    Be the first to leave a review.

    User Avatar
    {{{ review.rating_title }}}
    {{{review.rating_comment | nl2br}}}

    Show more
    {{ pageNumber+1 }}
    Leave your rating

     

    FitBit Aria

    3.6 Our Overall Score
    0 User Overall Score (0 votes)
    Summary of Pros
  • Tracks weight loss
  • Easy to use
  • Easy setup, with youtube video
  • Multiple user profiles and user recognition
  • Automatically syncs your data
  • Syncs with the FitBit and MyFitnessPal Apps
  • Graphs your progress
  • Appealing Design
  • Summary of Cons
  • Accuracy and consistency issues
  • Software bugs
  • User recognition glitches
  • Old models may have short life-cycle
  • Multi-user glitches
  • No Apple Health App
  • No Bluetooth Sync
  • In Depth Analysis
         
    The Good:
     
  • Setup: Easy, fast setup over WiFi. FitBit even provides a YouTube video that walks you through the setup.
  • User Profiles: Saves user profiles for you and other users.
  • Step Right Up:The scale automatically turns on and measures your stats when you step up on it.
  • User Recognition: Built to recognize you when you step onto the device.
  • Auto Sync: FitBit Aria will automatically sync with the FREE FitBit App and with MyFitnessPal if you so choose.
  • Average Weight:If you weigh in multiple times in a day, Aria will provide an average for the day.
  • Has its own App:You get access to the free FitBit App which provides all kinds of tracking and graphing benefits, and works with other FitBit devices.
  • Never lose data: If network is down, the scale keeps a record of your weigh-in and updates when reconnected.
  • Customer Support: Customer support seems very responsive and can be found all throughout complains on Amazon providing assistance.
  •    
    The Bad:
     
  • Weight Accuracy:Body Weight can be off and fluctuate by ounces. It is highly recommended that you weigh yourself three times in a row, as the third weight will be most accurate.
  • Body-fat Accuracy: Body-fat % on this (and basically all scales) is inaccurate.
  • Consistency: Users find a lack of consistency.
  • Multi-user bugs: Multi-user profiles can be glitchy, sometimes not properly detecting who stepped on the scale. Some users complain of the scale recognizing them as a guest or a different user.
  • PC Setup plain sucks!:Don't even bother with PC setup, it's a serious pain. Mobile setup is simple and functional.
  • No Apple Health App syncNo Apple Health App syncing for Apple users.
  • Don't bump it!Some users complain that they bump the scale throughout the day, causing it to turn on and therefore drain the batteries. The simple solution to this? Keep it away from heavy foot traffic!
  •    
    Final Word
      The FitBit Aria is another good smart scale with some flaws. It will simplify tracking your progress, whether the goal is weight loss or weight gain. It will give you some cool stats and graphs to assist in your journey to better health. Since its initial release many of the initial issues have been resolved, though some user complaints are still there. FitBit seems to be willing to work their customers. If you like the FitBit line and/or already own one of their many FitBit Activity Trackers, this scale is probably a no-brainer. Easy tracking, progress graphs, syncing with apps and devices...simplify your life!

    Buy the FitBit Aria Now

    Fitbit Aria Smart Scale Weight Loss Weight Track Buy Now
    Hardware
    Software
    Ease of Use
    Fun Factor
    Cost/Value
    What people say about the product... Leave your rating
    Sort by:

    Be the first to leave a review.

    User Avatar
    {{{ review.rating_title }}}
    {{{review.rating_comment | nl2br}}}

    Show more
    {{ pageNumber+1 }}
    Leave your rating

     

    Garmin Index

    3.3/5 Our Overall Score
    0 User Overall Score (0 votes)
    Summary of Pros
  • Tracks weight loss
  • Setup works via WiFi, bluetooth, or ANT+ USB
  • Measures body fat/water percentage
  • Measures bone & muscle mass
  • Multiple user profiles and user recognition
  • Automatically syncs your data
  • Syncs with Garmin's App, Garmin Connect
  • Graphs your progress
  • High quality hardware
  • Appealing Design
  • Highly responsive customer service
  • Summary of Cons
  • Accuracy and consistency issues
  • Software bugs
  • User recognition glitches
  • Multi-user glitches
  • Issues automatically applying updates
  • Stores only 1 daily weigh in
  • Does not store your data if connection is down
  • App offers more functionality than web platform
  • In Depth Analysis
         
    The Good:
     
  • Setup: Setup works via bluetooth, wifi, or ANT+USB. It's fairly easy and quick, although some users have more trouble than others. We are not sure what causes the variation here.
  • Additional measurements: Unlike most scales, Garmin Index measures water percentage, bone mass and muscle mass. Gain insight into the overall composition of your body!
  • Superb hardware and design: The hardware on this thing is seriously high quality and solid. Oh, and it looks good, too.
  • Has its own App: Works with the Garmin Connect, an app available with Garmin's other devices, such as their smart watches.
  • Auto Sync: Automatically syncs your data to Garmin Connect and MyFitnessPal if you so choose.
  • User Profiles: Saves user profiles for you and other users. Other users must also have the Garmin Connect App
  • Step Right Up: No calibration before you weigh in. Just step right onto the scale.
  • User Recognition: Built to recognize you when you step onto the device.
  • Customer Support: Customer support is EXTREMELY responsive and will work with any issues you may have.
  •    
    The Bad:
     
  • Accuracy: Although some users find the scale to be accurate, there are issues with both accuracy and consistency. Multiple weigh ins will give results with a lot of variation.
  • User recognition: Like every other smart scale in this article, Garmin Index sometimes fails to accurately recognize the user. Try, try again.
  • Multi-user bugs: There are some reports of difficulty setting up multiple users. Keep in mind all users must have the Garmin Connect App with their own profiles.
  • Auto-update: Sometimes the updates, which are supposed to be automatic, must be forced to apply.
  • Only ONE daily weigh in Garmin Index only stores your last weigh in of the day, overriding any previous measurements. This will not work well for someone who likes to check their fluctuations or obtain an average for the day.
  • No data storage when connection lost: Pretty self-explanatory. If you lose your WiFi connection, the scale does not keep a log of your data.
  •    
    Final Word
      The Garmin Index is a smart scale we are sort of struggling to come to a conclusion on. It has so much potential, but like most smart scales, falls short. The hardware on this thing is likely the best of all of the scales. The fact that it offers bone and muscle mass readings, something most other smart scales don't offer, is one of the major appeals of the Garmin Index. However some of the software issues and missing features are disappointing. The good thing is, Garmin is actively listening and talking to the customers. We hope they are taking what everyone is saying to heart and applying the insight to future software updates. The Garmin Index is newer than a lot of the other popular smart scales and hasn't had nearly as many users testing it out. Given some time, it may very well surpass the other scales. I guess we'll find out!
    Hardware
    Software
    Ease of Use
    Fun Factor
    Cost/Value
    What people say about the product... Leave your rating
    Sort by:

    Be the first to leave a review.

    User Avatar
    {{{ review.rating_title }}}
    {{{review.rating_comment | nl2br}}}

    Show more
    {{ pageNumber+1 }}
    Leave your rating

    facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterest